The confrontation in the small fishing town of Algoma, located on Lake Michigan, began with a Facebook post earlier this month. An anonymous individual expressed concern about the vandalism of political signs in the community, suggesting that “kindness should always win.”
In response, Dennis Paul, a 65-year-old resident, made sharp comments on the post, as did his neighbor Abbey Bridges, a 40-year-old Democrat. The exchange escalated when Mr. Paul shouted insults at Ms. Bridges while she was walking her dog, prompting her to call the police.
Algoma is known for its charm and tourism, featuring charter fishing trips and antique shops. However, it is also recognized for its significant political divide, with the community being nearly evenly split between supporters of President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump.
In the 2020 presidential election, Biden won in Algoma by just six votes. As the current election approaches, tensions in the town have intensified, affecting interactions among residents. Neighbors witnessed the police mediating disputes, and the area near Mr. Paul and Ms. Bridges’ homes has been dubbed “the crazy corner” due to the numerous political signs.
Some residents have attempted to maintain neutrality, while others openly display their political affiliations. Tensions have also arisen within families, with disagreements over key political issues such as immigration and reproductive rights.
Local officials are noticing the impact of the political divide. Algoma's police chief reported incidents requiring police intervention, including vandalism of political signs and complaints about improper sign placements.
Despite the divisions, many residents emphasize their care for one another, regardless of political beliefs. Community gatherings often reflect a mix of political opinions, with residents navigating their differences in a small-town environment.
Following the incident between Mr. Paul and Ms. Bridges, the two neighbors have avoided each other, with Ms. Bridges keeping her shades drawn to prevent contact. Mr. Paul, who actively supports Trump, expressed confusion over the hostility directed at him and noted the challenges he faces in the politically charged atmosphere.
As the election approaches, the atmosphere in Algoma remains tense, with residents concerned about how the outcome may affect their community dynamics.