The waterfront in Lahaina, Maui, has undergone numerous transformations over the centuries, from being the home of Hawaiian royalty to a stop for whalers, missionaries, and plantation owners. A devastating fire a year ago destroyed many historical relics, prompting a debate on how to rebuild the town. Some, like community leader Archie Kalepa, advocate for prioritizing the town's deeper history over economic interests, suggesting the removal of gift shops and restaurants to restore the town's original character. The debate also involves proposals to revamp neighborhoods, restore former wetlands, and emphasize the Indigenous past. However, there is opposition from property owners with deep ties to the area, who argue that they are an integral part of the community's history. The rebuilding process is further complicated by concerns about rising sea levels, erosion, and the need to relocate residents. The article highlights the challenges and complexities involved in deciding the future of Lahaina's waterfront and the broader town.